We were STATIONARY and somehow found at fault?? His insurance is unreal

Not doubting you at all, but a couple of questions that might come up: when you say engine off, do you have any way to prove that — like did your friend who was in the store see the car parked before they went in? And the 'encroaching on the line' claim — do you know for certain where your tires were relative to the stall lines? Just want you to think through what the other side is going to push on so you're ready.

This makes me so angry on your behalf. You did everything right — stayed calm, exchanged info responsibly, filed promptly — and now you're being punished for it while the guy who actually caused this just... gets away with lying? Please don't let this drop. You deserve to have the record reflect what actually happened.

Not legal advice, but from a practical standpoint: if there's any security footage, get a preservation letter sent to that garage NOW before their system overwrites it — most systems loop every 14–30 days. Witness statements, photos showing your tire position relative to the painted lines, anything that establishes you were properly parked all matters here. A lot of PI attorneys will do a free consult and can tell you pretty quickly if this is worth pushing. The fact that you haven't signed anything is good.

Their insurance's job is to protect THEIR insured, full stop. When they say 'our investigation found you partially at fault,' what they really mean is 'our guy told us a story and we're going with it.' Don't treat that determination like it's some neutral official verdict — it's not. You can absolutely dispute it.

Went through something almost identical in a shopping center lot. Other driver lied, their insurance sided with him, I was a wreck about it. What turned it around for me was finding a witness — someone who'd seen the whole thing from a nearby car and hadn't said anything because they assumed someone else would. Sounds like a long shot but do you remember if anyone was around? Worth posting on a local community group or even a Nextdoor for that area.

Just want to ask — are you physically okay? Sometimes people are so focused on the car and the insurance mess that they don't notice they've been holding tension in their neck or back since the impact. Even a low-speed parking lot scrape can jar you. If anything feels off, please get checked out. It also creates a medical record tied to the date of the incident, which matters if this escalates.

Three things: 1) Chase that garage footage today, not tomorrow. 2) Write down every single detail you remember about the scene while it's still fresh — your exact spot number, which direction his truck came from, everything. 3) Stop talking to his insurance without your own insurer or an attorney on the line. You've already given your statement; there's no upside to more conversations with them.

A few things worth knowing: the at-fault insurer's liability determination is not legally binding on you. You can file a complaint with your state's department of insurance if you believe the investigation was one-sided. Also, your own insurer has a duty to advocate for you — I'd call them today and specifically ask what they have determined about liability and whether they'll be going after the other carrier. Sometimes your carrier will subrogate (basically fight the other side on your behalf) if they pay out first.