The Shoulder
The Shoulder
46
Property damageswift-heron-925

Totaled car got crushed before insurance even looked at it — what now??

I'm honestly losing my mind over this situation and hoping someone here has been through something similar.

About six weeks ago a driver ran a red light and slammed into my car. Police came, I filed a report, my car got towed to some impound lot. I was shaken up and dealing with doctor visits so I assumed the insurance side of things was moving along in the background.

Fast forward to last week — I finally feel well enough to really dig into the claim and I call the adjuster to ask about the vehicle inspection and a rental reimbursement. They basically tell me they haven't even located the car yet. I'm like... what? So I call the impound lot myself. Turns out my car was already sold to a salvage yard and crushed. Gone. No one from insurance ever saw it.

How is this even legal? The whole point of a physical inspection is to document the damage. Now there's literally nothing left to inspect. I have photos I took at the scene and a police report, but I'm worried the insurance company is going to use this as an excuse to lowball me or drag the claim out forever.

A few things I'm not sure about:

  • Does the burden shift to them now since they dropped the ball on locating the vehicle?
  • Can my photos + the police report be enough to establish the damage?
  • Should I be talking to anyone besides the adjuster at this point?

I'm already dealing with a neck injury from the crash and the last thing I need is to fight tooth and nail over a car that literally no longer exists. Any advice or shared experiences would mean a lot right now.

13replies

Not sure what your claim is worth?

AskMatlock can connect you with an independent injury lawyer for a free case check — no pressure, no cost to start.

Check my case

0 / 4000 · posted under a randomly assigned handle

13 replies

  • 20
    wise-wolf-849

    Oh man, I went through something similar — not quite the same but my car sat at an impound for weeks while the insurance companies argued over liability and nobody told me anything. The communication from adjusters is just awful sometimes. Document EVERYTHING you have right now — every photo, every text, every voicemail. That paper trail saved me when things got messy.

    • 18
      candid-crow-349

      Please do not let them use the missing car as leverage to pay you less. That is 100% something adjusters will try. They'll say they 'can't verify the damage' and suddenly your payout shrinks. Push back hard and get everything in writing from this point forward. No more phone-only conversations.

  • 14
    patient-lynx-466

    Worked in auto claims for years. Honestly this is more common than people think and it's usually a breakdown between the tow company, the impound lot, and the insurer's total-loss department — nobody's watching the clock on the storage fees and the lot eventually exercises their lien rights and sells the vehicle.

    Here's the thing though: the insurer is NOT off the hook just because the car is gone. Your photos, the police report, and any repair estimates you might have gotten can all be used to establish value. The adjuster may push back but that's a negotiating position, not the final word. Keep escalating if they stall.

    • 9
      tired-survivor912

      Seconding this. The same approach worked for me last year.

  • 21
    sharp-bison-409

    A few things worth knowing: most states have specific rules about how long an impound lot has to notify the registered owner and lienholder before disposing of a vehicle. It's worth pulling up your state's DMV or towing statutes to see if the lot even followed proper procedure — if they didn't, that opens up another avenue entirely.

    Also, request the full claim file in writing. You're entitled to it, and seeing the internal notes can tell you a lot about whether the adjuster actually did anything or just let it sit.

    • 6
      steady-survivor763

      Thanks for sharing. Hope things are getting a little easier for you.

  • 13
    humble-hare-933

    Can I just check in about the neck injury real quick? Please make sure you're still keeping all your medical appointments and not letting the stress of this insurance nightmare cause you to skip follow-ups. Gaps in treatment can actually hurt you later if there's any injury claim involved. Take care of yourself first — the car stuff is stressful but your health is the priority.

    • 3
      hopeful-passenger686

      That lines up with what my adjuster told me too.

  • 10
    warm-grouse-216

    Not legal advice, but this scenario — vehicle disposed of before inspection, documented injuries, an at-fault third party — is exactly the kind of situation where a free consultation with a PI attorney is worth your time. There may be multiple parties with exposure here including the impound lot depending on how the disposal went down. Most personal injury attorneys handle the property damage piece too when it's connected to an injury claim.

    • 0
      thankful-sidewalk763

      Exactly my experience. Persistence paid off in the end.

  • 17
    careful-stoat-061

    Stop trying to resolve this through the regular adjuster line. Ask to speak to a supervisor or file a complaint with your state's department of insurance. Adjusters move a lot faster when there's a regulator potentially watching. Also get your photos organized chronologically with timestamps visible and save them somewhere that isn't just your phone.

  • 9
    quiet-beaver-892

    This is so unfair and I'm really sorry you're dealing with it on top of recovering from an injury. You did nothing wrong here — you reported everything, you cooperated. The system just failed you. I really hope you get some resolution soon. Rooting for you.

    • 6
      curious-traveler478

      Really glad you posted an update — gives the rest of us some hope.