The Shoulder
The Shoulder
72
Legal questionshearty-marmot-052

Torn rotator cuff + nerve damage from crash — is an attorney actually worth it for me?

So I'm about 3 months out from a pretty bad rear-end collision and still not sure if I should hire a PI attorney or just handle the claim myself. Wanted to get some real opinions from people who've been through it.

Here's where I'm at medically: partial rotator cuff tear in my shoulder, some nerve impingement in my cervical spine, and soft tissue damage running down my arm. My orthopedic surgeon and a neurologist are both involved, plus I've been doing PT twice a week. Progress is slow — I can lift my arm overhead again but not without pain. The nerve stuff is what really scares me because my neuro said it may not fully resolve.

The problem is my job. I do mobile dog grooming — it's my own little business — and I physically cannot do everything I used to. Lifting large dogs, the repetitive motion with clippers and brushes... I've had to turn away clients and bring in a helper I'm paying out of pocket. That's direct income loss that's hard to document cleanly because I'm self-employed.

I talked to one attorney who said there's no upfront cost, contingency only, and I can walk away if I don't like where it's heading. That felt reassuring but I'm still second-guessing.

Main questions:

  • Does the nerve damage + permanent shoulder stuff change the math on needing representation?
  • Anyone self-employed deal with proving lost income to insurers?
  • Is the 'you can walk away anytime' thing standard or a red flag?

Any thoughts genuinely appreciated. This has been a brutal few months.

12replies

Not sure what your claim is worth?

AskMatlock can connect you with an independent injury lawyer for a free case check — no pressure, no cost to start.

Check my case

0 / 4000 · posted under a randomly assigned handle

12 replies

  • 17
    quick-stoat-325

    The self-employed income loss thing is REAL and it's brutal to navigate alone. I'm a freelance photographer and after my accident the adjuster basically laughed at my "proof" of lost work because I didn't have pay stubs. An attorney helped me pull together tax returns, client invoices, and a statement from my accountant that actually made the case. Do not try to fight that part by yourself.

  • 20
    tidy-elk-832

    Not legal advice, but I'll say this — nerve damage that 'may not fully resolve' is exactly the kind of thing that changes a claim's value significantly. Future medical costs, ongoing impact on your ability to work, pain and suffering that extends years out... that's not something a standard adjuster is going to volunteer to calculate in your favor. The contingency structure you described is pretty standard and the walk-away piece is normal. Worth at least finishing the consultation process.

  • 19
    bold-lynx-377

    Please please please do not settle this yourself. The moment you mention nerve damage to an adjuster, they know it's serious — and their job is to close your file for as little as possible before you figure out what it's actually worth. They are NOT on your side, even if they sound sympathetic on the phone.

    • 2
      soft-spoken-sidewalk645

      Took me three tries but they finally budged. Don't give up.

  • 22
    daring-sparrow-229

    I used to work claims and I'll be honest with you — files with soft tissue plus documented nerve involvement plus self-employment income loss are ones we flagged as 'complicated to value.' That's adjuster code for 'we need to move this person fast before they get help.' The 'walk away anytime' clause in a contingency agreement is completely standard, not a red flag. If anything it shows they're confident enough they don't need to lock you in.

    • 12
      bright-hare-337

      Quick question — did the other driver's insurance already make you an offer, or are you still in the middle of treatment? Because the timing of when you settle matters a lot with something like nerve damage where you don't fully know the outcome yet. I'd be curious what your neurologist's actual prognosis language is, because 'may not resolve' is pretty vague.

  • 10
    silent-finch-937

    From a medical standpoint, cervical nerve impingement that's still symptomatic at 3 months needs to be tracked really carefully. Make sure your neurologist is documenting every appointment with specifics — numbness levels, strength testing, any changes. That paper trail matters enormously down the road whether you settle in 6 months or 2 years. A lot of people stop going to appointments once they feel 'a little better' and then regret it.

    • 0
      kind-rider615

      Curious whether you did this on your own or had help with it.

  • 15
    warm-swift-321

    Get the attorney. Partial rotator cuff tear + nerve damage + you're self-employed and losing income = too many moving parts to wing it. The contingency thing is how literally every PI attorney works. Stop overthinking it.

  • 13
    wise-dove-067

    I just want to say I'm really sorry you're going through this. Running your own business AND dealing with injuries that affect your actual ability to do the work sounds exhausting and stressful in a way most people don't understand. I hope you get some clarity soon. 💙

  • 17
    gentle-lynx-530

    One thing I'll say — the fact that you caught the nerve involvement early and have a neurologist already in the picture puts you in a better spot than a lot of people who don't get that diagnosed until months later. You have documentation. That's actually a real advantage going into a claim.

    • 6
      calm-passenger685

      Wish I had seen this a month ago — would have saved me a lot of stress.