The Shoulder
The Shoulder
65
careful-swift-648

Rented a car on vacation, got into a wreck with a semi — no liability coverage. What now??

I'm honestly panicking a little and could use some perspective from people who've been through something like this.

I'm here on a student visa and rented a car to do a road trip over spring break. On the second day, I was changing lanes on the highway when an 18-wheeler clipped my rear bumper pretty hard. The truck driver is claiming I cut him off, but from my side it felt like he sped up right as I was merging. There was a police report and the officer noted both of our accounts.

Here's where I messed up: at the rental counter I was trying to save money and waved off the extra liability coverage they offered. I also thought the travel insurance I bought before the trip would cover everything — turns out it only covers me medically, not damage I cause to someone else's vehicle.

The trucker isn't with a big company — looks like he runs independently and hauls contract loads. He hasn't sent me anything formal yet but he did call me once asking about insurance. I told him I'd look into it. I'm terrified he's going to come after me personally.

Questions swirling in my head:

  • Am I personally on the hook for his truck repairs if fault lands on me?
  • Does being an international student change anything legally?
  • How long does this whole thing usually drag out?
  • Should I be talking to a lawyer even if I have no money right now?

I don't really have family here who understand US insurance law and I'm just trying to figure out what steps to take so I don't make things worse. Any advice is appreciated 🙏

13replies

Not sure what your claim is worth?

AskMatlock can connect you with an independent injury lawyer for a free case check — no pressure, no cost to start.

Check my case

0 / 4000 · posted under a randomly assigned handle

13 replies

  • 20
    bold-kestrel-409

    A couple of practical things:

    • Pull together everything right now: the police report number, your rental agreement, any photos from the scene, the trucker's contact info, and a written timeline of what happened while it's fresh.
    • Check whether your credit card has any auto rental coverage built in — some cards include third-party liability, though it varies a lot by card and situation. Worth a call to your card issuer.
    • If you get served with anything formal (a demand letter, a lawsuit), that starts a clock. Don't sit on it.
  • 20
    silent-beaver-161

    Here's the blunt version: you're in a tough spot but not a hopeless one. Stop answering the trucker's calls and let everything go through writing from here on out. Get a free consult with a PI lawyer ASAP — many will see you for free and can at least tell you how exposed you actually are. And yes, the visa situation adds stress but it doesn't change the civil liability math.

    • 2
      weathered-offramp914

      This thread is gold. Thanks everyone.

  • 17
    humble-owl-816

    Oh man, I felt this post in my chest. I was in a somewhat similar spot a couple years ago — rented a car, skipped the counter insurance, and ended up in a fender bender that turned into a whole ordeal. The short answer is: yes, without liability coverage you can be personally responsible for the other party's damages. It doesn't automatically mean someone will sue you or collect, but the exposure is real. Please don't ignore the trucker's calls — that usually makes things worse.

    • 0
      calm-passenger545

      Solid advice. Getting it in writing is the part most people skip.

  • 13
    bright-marmot-350

    Former auto adjuster here. A few things to know from the inside:

    1. Fault isn't always binary — many states allow comparative or contributory fault, which means even if you were partly responsible, the trucker might share some blame too (blind spots are a real factor and adjusters are trained to look at that). 2. An independent owner-operator almost certainly has some form of commercial liability insurance — federal regulations require it for trucks above a certain weight. He may be downplaying that to pressure you directly. 3. Do NOT make any payments or sign anything until you know exactly what you're dealing with.

    • 21
      clear-marmot-640

      Not legal advice, but: being an international student doesn't make you more or less liable under civil law — you're subject to the same rules as anyone else in that state. What matters is the evidence around fault. Truck drivers have specific duties regarding blind spot awareness, and that's actually worth exploring. A lot of PI attorneys do free consultations and some work on contingency even for defendants in complex situations. Worth at least one conversation before you assume the worst.

  • 11
    bright-heron-832

    I really feel for you — navigating this stuff is hard enough when you grew up here, let alone when you're in a foreign country on a student visa trying to figure it all out alone. Please don't try to handle this by yourself. Even just talking to a lawyer once will probably make you feel way less like the walls are closing in.

    • 3
      careful-dreamer255

      How long did it end up taking in your case?

  • 9
    tidy-raven-302

    Just checking — are you okay physically? Sometimes the stress of the legal side overshadows the fact that a collision with a semi can cause injuries that don't show up right away. If you have any neck stiffness, headaches, or back pain that started after the crash, please see a doctor and document it. That matters for your own protection too.

  • 5
    kind-marmot-161

    Just want to flag something: if that trucker's insurance company gets involved (even commercial truckers often have some coverage), their adjuster is going to be looking for every reason to pin 100% fault on you. Don't give recorded statements to anyone without understanding what you're signing up for. Adjusters are trained to get you to say things that hurt your case.

    • 2
      calm-rider612

      Thanks for sharing. Hope things are getting a little easier for you.

    • 7
      soft-spoken-late-shift894

      Did the timeline change anything for you? Mine dragged on for weeks.