The Shoulder
The Shoulder
66
Insurancecalm-mole-873

Other driver's insurance keeps pushing me to settle and I'm still in PT — is this normal??

So I got rear-ended about a month ago at a stoplight. The other driver literally got out of his car and apologized on the spot, so liability isn't really in dispute. His insurance has been weirdly... nice. Like almost too nice.

They called me within days of the accident, got my car sorted out fast, and now they keep emailing asking if I'm ready to 'close out the injury portion' of my claim. The adjuster has used the phrase 'get you taken care of' probably four times. I don't know why but it gives me a bad feeling.

Here's the thing — I'm still going to physical therapy twice a week. My shoulder and upper back are genuinely messed up. My PT said it's too early to know if I'll need further treatment or imaging. I haven't even hit my deductible yet this year and the bills are already adding up.

I've never dealt with anything like this before. Part of me wants to just take the money and move on because the whole thing is exhausting and stressful. But another part of me wonders if I settle now and my shoulder gets worse in two months, am I just... stuck?

Has anyone been pressured like this while still in treatment? Did you settle early and regret it, or did waiting actually make a difference? I feel like I'm flying blind here and I don't want to make a huge mistake.

12replies

Not sure what your claim is worth?

AskMatlock can connect you with an independent injury lawyer for a free case check — no pressure, no cost to start.

Check my case

0 / 4000 · posted under a randomly assigned handle

12 replies

  • 12
    clear-mole-080

    That 'get you taken care of' language is a huge red flag to me. They are NOT trying to take care of you — they're trying to close the file before you know the full extent of your injuries. The faster they settle, the less they pay. Full stop. Do not sign anything while you're still in treatment.

    • 10
      bright-finch-094

      I used to work claims and I'll be real with you — when an adjuster pushes this hard this fast, it's almost always because they know the injury has more value than the offer on the table. We were literally evaluated on how quickly we closed files. 'Nice' adjusters closing things early is one of the oldest plays in the book. Once you sign a release, it is over. Doesn't matter if you need surgery six weeks later.

  • 6
    calm-lynx-187

    I was in almost this exact situation two years ago. Settled early because I was tired of dealing with it and honestly needed the money. My back got significantly worse about three months later and I had zero recourse. Zero. I wish someone had told me to just wait until my doctor actually discharged me from treatment. Please don't make the same call I did.

    • 1
      patient-passenger918

      This is really helpful — thank you for posting it.

  • 17
    brave-bison-997

    From a medical standpoint, a month is really not long enough to understand the trajectory of a soft tissue injury, especially to the shoulder and upper back. Some of these injuries plateau quickly, others don't peak in terms of symptoms until 8–12 weeks out. Your PT saying it's too early to know is actually really significant — that's a medical professional telling you the picture isn't complete yet. I'd take that seriously before making any financial decisions.

    • 0
      tired-walker296

      Really glad you posted an update — gives the rest of us some hope.

    • 2
      level-co-pilot884

      Following up on this — any update on how it turned out?

  • 7
    warm-newt-392

    A couple of practical things to know: when you settle a personal injury claim and sign a release, you're typically waiving ALL future claims related to that accident — even injuries that get worse or conditions that weren't fully diagnosed yet. That's just how releases work. You generally want to be at what's called 'maximum medical improvement' (MMI) before settling, because that's when your doctors have a clearer picture of long-term impact. You're nowhere near that point based on what you've described.

  • 22
    humble-lynx-654

    Not legal advice, but this pattern — fast contact, quick car resolution, pressure to settle injury before treatment ends — is extremely common and the timing is intentional. Most attorneys who handle these cases would tell you not to discuss 'injury resolution' with the other party's insurer at all until treatment is complete. A free consultation with a PI attorney costs you nothing and could at least help you understand what you might be giving up. Just worth a call.

  • 6
    calm-heron-609

    You already answered your own question when you wrote 'my PT said it's too early to know.' That's it. That's the reason not to settle. Don't overcomplicate this — just tell the adjuster you're still under active medical care and you'll reach out when your treatment is complete. You don't owe them a timeline.

  • 20
    quiet-marmot-971

    Honestly just the fact that you have a bad feeling about it is worth paying attention to. You don't have to be an expert to know when something feels off. Please don't let them exhaust you into a bad decision — that's literally what they're counting on.

  • 7
    curious-wolf-533

    What exactly are they offering for the injury portion — is it a lump sum or are they offering to cover medical bills only? And have they asked you to sign anything yet or is it still just phone/email pressure? The specifics matter a lot here because there's a difference between them floating a number casually versus actually sending you a release to sign.