The Shoulder
The Shoulder
70
Insurancehearty-elk-081

Driver who hit me begging me to keep insurance out of it — do I just say no?

So this happened two days ago and I'm still kind of rattled. I was sitting at a red light, completely stopped, when I got slammed from behind. Hit was hard enough that my car got pushed a few feet forward. The other driver was a younger woman — she was apologetic and we exchanged info, but she seemed really nervous.

Fast forward to yesterday morning and I get a call from her mom. Super friendly at first, then basically pleading with me to handle this without going through insurance. Said a rate increase would be a real financial hardship for their family and asked if we could just 'come to an agreement' between ourselves.

Here's the thing — I haven't even gotten a repair estimate yet. I don't actually know what the damage to my car looks like once a shop gets eyes on it. And more importantly, I woke up the morning after the crash with a stiff neck and some shoulder pain I did not have before. Nothing feels broken but it's definitely not nothing either.

I told her I'd think about it, which I probably shouldn't have said, but I felt put on the spot.

My gut says file a claim, period. What if the body damage is worse than it looks? What if my neck situation gets worse over the next few weeks? If I take some cash handshake deal now and something develops later, I'm just stuck, right?

Has anyone dealt with pressure like this? Did you hold firm or did you make an exception and regret it?

16replies

Not sure what your claim is worth?

AskMatlock can connect you with an independent injury lawyer for a free case check — no pressure, no cost to start.

Check my case

0 / 4000 · posted under a randomly assigned handle

16 replies

  • 15
    daring-elk-586

    The moment they called you and asked you to stay off insurance, the dynamic shifted. That's not a favor they're asking — that's them managing their own risk at your expense. Their financial situation is genuinely not your problem to absorb here. You got hit. You didn't ask for any of this.

    • 7
      weary-parent304

      Solid advice. Getting it in writing is the part most people skip.

  • 14
    kind-wren-619

    One thing people often don't realize: if you skip the claim and then try to file later because your injury got worse, it gets messy. Delayed reporting raises questions. You want a clear paper trail from the start — police report if you can get one, claim filed promptly, medical visit documented close to the date of the crash. That timeline matters a lot if anything escalates.

    • 8
      soft-spoken-sidewalk411

      Thank you both, this gave me the push I needed to make the call.

  • 14
    curious-sparrow-524

    Did you get a police report at all, or just exchange info? And when you say your neck hurts — have you actually seen a doctor or just hoping it goes away? Asking because both of those things affect what your options even look like right now.

    • 4
      grounded-road-soul461

      Exactly my experience. Persistence paid off in the end.

  • 13
    silent-beaver-685

    Honestly the fact that they called you at all makes me a little uneasy. Like, it was their driver who hit you and now somehow you're the one being asked to absorb the inconvenience? Please just take care of yourself here.

    • 5
      steady-traveler138

      Solid advice. Getting it in writing is the part most people skip.

  • 9
    hearty-finch-337

    Not legal advice, but I'll say this generally: verbal agreements to 'handle it privately' are almost impossible to enforce if the other party changes their mind or can't pay. And if your injury develops into something requiring real treatment, you'd have no recourse. Filing through insurance preserves your options. Not filing closes them. That's the basic calculus.

    • 4
      careful-traveler169

      Curious whether you did this on your own or had help with it.

  • 8
    quick-crow-545

    I used to work on the insurance side and I can tell you — the families who ask you to skip the claim are almost always thinking about their own premium, not your wellbeing. There's also no guarantee they'd actually pay you what the repair ends up costing once they see the bill. Private agreements fall apart constantly. The insurance system exists for exactly this reason.

  • 7
    steady-hare-096

    You already have the answer. You said it yourself — you don't know the full damage yet and your body is already giving you signals. A handshake deal closes the door on both of those unknowns. Say no, file, move on.

  • 5
    quiet-wolf-736

    I was in almost this exact situation a couple years ago. Different circumstances but same guilt trip, same 'let's keep insurance out of it' ask. I felt bad for them and agreed to wait while we 'figured it out.' Two weeks later my back pain was bad enough I needed an MRI and suddenly they stopped returning my calls. File the claim. Protect yourself first.

    • 6
      calm-survivor511

      Really glad you posted an update — gives the rest of us some hope.

  • 5
    hearty-crow-590

    Please don't brush off the neck and shoulder pain. Soft tissue injuries from rear-end collisions can feel mild for a few days and then get significantly worse. I've seen patients who felt 'a little stiff' and ended up needing weeks of physical therapy. Get checked out by a doctor and make sure everything is documented regardless of what you decide about the claim.

    • 10
      weary-driver909

      Seconding this. The same approach worked for me last year.