The Shoulder
The Shoulder
50
careful-otter-089

At-fault driver wrecked my car right before I needed it for a cross-country move — can I claim those costs?

So I'm beyond frustrated right now and just need to hear from people who've dealt with something similar.

About two weeks ago I got hit pretty badly at an intersection — totally the other driver's fault, she ran a red light and T-boned me. My car is drivable but the frame damage is significant and the shop says it's going to be tied up for at least three weeks minimum.

Here's the problem: I had already arranged to drive all my stuff across several states to my new place. I'm relocating to be near my aging parents, something I've been planning for months. With my car stuck in a body shop, I'm now looking at renting a cargo van, paying for flights back, and scrambling to figure out how to get my stuff there at all. We're talking potentially $1,500–$2,500 in extra costs that have nothing to do with the car repair itself.

My insurance is handling the vehicle damage through a claim and going after her carrier for reimbursement. The liability side seems straightforward — she literally ran a red on a dashcam that caught the whole thing.

My real question is: can I submit those moving-related expenses as part of my claim against her insurance? Like the van rental, the flights, maybe even a night in a hotel because the timing got thrown off? Is there any way to document this so it actually gets taken seriously, or will adjusters just laugh at it?

I saved all my original moving confirmations and receipts so I can prove the plans existed before the accident. Just not sure if "consequential" expenses like this are even on the table.

Anyone been through something like this? Really appreciate any insight. 🙏

11replies

Not sure what your claim is worth?

AskMatlock can connect you with an independent injury lawyer for a free case check — no pressure, no cost to start.

Check my case

0 / 4000 · posted under a randomly assigned handle

11 replies

  • 17
    clear-badger-485

    Document everything. Every single receipt. Write a short timeline — accident date, car drop-off date, shop estimate for completion, your original move date — and attach it to the receipts when you submit. Make it impossible for them to claim you didn't prove the connection. And do it all in writing via email so you have a record.

    • 6
      honest-passenger401

      Thanks for sharing. Hope things are getting a little easier for you.

  • 15
    daring-wolf-159

    Don't be surprised if the adjuster tries to tell you those costs are "not covered" right out of the gate. That's often just an opening position, not the final word. They're trained to say no first and see who pushes back. If you have solid documentation and the liability is clear-cut like you're describing, push back in writing. Emails create a paper trail. Phone calls don't.

  • 13
    candid-newt-519

    I went through something weirdly similar — not a move, but I had a pre-paid work trip that got derailed when my car was in the shop after a rear-ender. I submitted the extra transportation costs as part of my claim and the adjuster actually paid out most of it once I showed them the original booking confirmations. The key for me was proving those plans existed before the accident and that the accident directly caused the extra expense. Your dashcam footage sounds like a huge plus — no liability fight means they're more likely to just settle the whole thing cleanly.

    • 12
      candid-bison-349

      What you're describing falls under what's sometimes called "consequential damages" — losses that flow directly from the accident even if they aren't the car repair itself. Whether or not the at-fault carrier covers it depends on the state and how you document the causal link. The fact that you have pre-accident moving confirmations is genuinely important. Put together a clear paper trail: original reservation dates, the accident report showing the date of loss, repair shop timeline, and then every new expense receipt. Present it as a package, not just random receipts. No guarantees, but organized documentation always helps.

  • 12
    quiet-hare-314

    Ugh, this is so stressful, I'm sorry. Moving is already a nightmare even when everything goes right. I really hope the insurance stuff works out — it seems so unfair that you're eating these extra costs when none of this was your fault. Hang in there.

    • 2
      gentle-wanderer779

      Did you have to escalate, or did they come around after the first ask?

  • 12
    spry-sparrow-478

    Quick question — did the body shop give you a written estimated completion date? Because if you're claiming the move delay was caused by the repair timeline, you'll want that documented formally, not just a verbal estimate from a tech. If you don't have it in writing, get it now before you submit anything.

  • 10
    calm-heron-975

    Not legal advice, but generally speaking, you can absolutely include out-of-pocket losses beyond the vehicle repair in a claim against an at-fault driver's liability coverage. The burden is on you to show those costs were a direct, foreseeable result of the accident — and your pre-existing moving plans help establish that. If the carrier pushes back hard, a quick consult with a PI attorney is worth it. Many do free consultations and can tell you pretty quickly if it's worth pursuing formally.

    • 6
      curious-survivor138

      Really glad you posted an update — gives the rest of us some hope.

  • 9
    genuine-dove-414

    Honestly, from the other side of the desk — the cleaner the liability, the more wiggle room adjusters have to approve things like this without it becoming a whole thing internally. When fault is disputed, everything gets scrutinized. When it's obvious like your dashcam situation, the file moves faster and there's less appetite for a fight over add-on expenses. That said, itemize everything and keep the amounts reasonable. Inflated claims raise flags even on clean files.