The Shoulder
The Shoulder
52
Legal questionsbrave-heron-041

At-fault driver just hired their OWN personal lawyer mid-lawsuit — is this normal??

Hey everyone, hoping someone here has seen this before because I'm genuinely confused and a little rattled.

Background: I was hit from behind at a red light about two years ago — pretty bad impact, needed a spinal procedure several months later. My attorney filed suit after the other driver's insurance kept lowballing us, and we've been in active litigation for a while now.

Out of nowhere, my lawyer tells me the at-fault driver went out and retained their own private attorney — completely separate from the one the insurance company already assigned them. Apparently the driver told someone they felt like the insurance company's lawyer wasn't looking out for their personal interests.

I didn't even know that was a thing people did? Like, doesn't the insurance company's lawyer already represent the driver? I get that there can be conflicts — especially if a verdict could come back higher than the policy covers — but the policy limits here are substantial and my attorney has been clear that our demand is reasonable relative to those limits.

So now I'm sitting here wondering:

  • Does this usually mean something is about to shift in the case strategy?
  • Should I read into this as a sign the driver is nervous about exposure beyond their policy?
  • Is this going to slow everything down or complicate settlement talks?

My own lawyer was pretty calm about it, said it's not unheard of, but I'm the one lying awake at 2am overthinking it. Anyone been through something like this or have any insight? I just want this resolved so I can move on with my life. 😩

14replies

Not sure what your claim is worth?

AskMatlock can connect you with an independent injury lawyer for a free case check — no pressure, no cost to start.

Check my case

0 / 4000 · posted under a randomly assigned handle

14 replies

  • 21
    spry-otter-870

    This exact thing happened in my case. The at-fault driver hired a separate attorney about six months into the lawsuit stage, and from what my lawyer explained, it usually means the driver got spooked about some kind of gap between their interests and the insurance company's interests. In my situation it actually ended up speeding things toward settlement because suddenly there were more people motivated to close the file. Try not to panic — I know that's easier said than done.

    • 4
      calm-rider755

      Appreciate the detailed write-up. Saving this for later.

  • 21
    bold-swift-221

    Not legal advice, but just so you understand the dynamic: an insurer's defense attorney technically represents the policyholder, but their client is effectively the insurance company that's paying the bills. When a driver feels that tension — especially if they're worried about personal exposure above policy limits, or just don't trust the insurer's strategy — hiring independent counsel is a legitimate move. It's called a 'Cumis counsel' situation in some states. The fact that your demand is reportedly within policy limits is worth noting, but only your attorney can really interpret what this means for your specific case.

  • 16
    sharp-lynx-945

    I used to work on the carrier side and honestly, when a defendant goes out and gets their own lawyer it usually means one of two things: either the driver got some letter from the insurer about a potential coverage issue, or they just genuinely don't trust that the adjuster has their back. Sometimes it's nothing dramatic. But it does introduce a new voice into settlement negotiations, and that can go either way — more pressure to resolve cleanly, or more chaos. Your attorney should be tracking this closely.

    • 6
      grounded-overpass904

      Following up on this — any update on how it turned out?

    • 9
      gentle-survivor250

      Seconding this. The same approach worked for me last year.

  • 6
    swift-otter-508

    The insurance company's lawyer is there to protect the insurance company's money, period. The driver probably figured that out and smartly got someone in their corner. Honestly, I'd focus on what YOUR lawyer is doing more than what's happening on their side — adjusters and defense attorneys will use every distraction they can to throw you off.

    • 13
      clever-elk-336

      Ugh, I can only imagine how stressful this feels after everything you've already been through — surgery, two years of fighting this, and now a curveball like this. I really hope it moves toward resolution soon. You deserve to just be done with all of it. 💙

    • 10
      weary-walker500

      Going through something similar right now. Did following up actually move the needle for you?

  • 18
    bright-lynx-608

    This comes up more than people think, especially once a case is in active litigation. From a process standpoint, the court will just need to get both defense attorneys added to the service list. It can create a little administrative shuffle but it doesn't derail anything fundamental. The bigger question is whether the two defense attorneys will coordinate or start pulling in different directions — your attorney will be watching for that.

    • 10
      careful-parent351

      Going through something similar right now. Did following up actually move the needle for you?

  • 17
    calm-mole-655

    How did your attorney find out the driver's reason for hiring separate counsel? Did the driver's new lawyer actually communicate that to your side, or is that just secondhand info? I'd want to know if there's something more specific going on — like an actual coverage dispute — versus the driver just being generally anxious. Those are pretty different situations.

    • 9
      tired-dreamer862

      Appreciate the detailed write-up. Saving this for later.

  • 19
    mellow-grouse-212

    Stop trying to decode their strategy and let your lawyer handle it. Seriously. You're not going to figure out what this means by losing sleep over it — your attorney is the one who can actually do something with the information. Ask them directly: 'Does this change our timeline or our settlement approach?' Get a real answer and then try to let go of the rest.