The Shoulder
The Shoulder
60
patient-marten-153

At-fault driver ghosted their own insurer so I had no choice but to file suit

I still can't believe this is where things ended up, but here we are.

Back in the spring I was rear-ended at a red light — pretty straightforward collision, the other driver admitted fault on the scene, we exchanged info, I even took photos of both vehicles and got the light to turn green on a dashcam before impact. Open and shut, right?

Wrong. Turns out the car the other driver was operating is registered and insured under a family member's policy — not him. Once I filed the claim, the insurance company says they've been trying to reach both the registered owner AND the driver for weeks and nobody is picking up, calling back, nothing. So they "suspended" my claim. Basically told me they couldn't proceed without a statement from their insured and there was nothing they could do for me right now.

Meanwhile I'm out of pocket for a rental, my neck and shoulder are still a mess, I've got physical therapy twice a week, and my car sat at the body shop for almost a month.

I waited. I sent a certified letter to the at-fault driver's last known address. I gave it another full month. Still nothing.

So last week I filed in civil court. Served the driver AND the registered owner. The second those papers landed on their doorstep, suddenly the insurance company called ME wanting to "reopen" the file.

Funny how that works.

Has anyone else been through this? Did filing suit actually move things forward for you, or did it drag on even longer? I feel like I did the right thing but I honestly have no idea what comes next.

12replies

Not sure what your claim is worth?

AskMatlock can connect you with an independent injury lawyer for a free case check — no pressure, no cost to start.

Check my case

0 / 4000 · posted under a randomly assigned handle

12 replies

  • 10
    tidy-wolf-348

    This is almost exactly what happened to me two years ago. The other driver's relative owned the car and neither of them would cooperate with their own insurance. The moment I filed and got them served, their insurer went from radio silence to blowing up my phone. Hang in there — it does seem to shake things loose.

  • 13
    sharp-bison-066

    That sudden callback from the insurance company is NOT them being helpful — it's damage control. They know that once there's an active lawsuit, their exposure gets much harder to manage. Do not agree to anything informal over the phone without something in writing. They will try to lowball you quickly and make it go away before this gets any further.

  • 16
    swift-lynx-578

    Worked claims for years. When a policyholder goes uncooperative, adjusters genuinely are stuck — they can't accept liability without a statement. But the second a suit is filed, it becomes a legal matter and the whole file escalates to a litigation unit with way more authority and budget to settle. So yes, what you're seeing is totally normal. That call you got is the litigation team waking up. Just don't let them rush you into a quick number before you know the full extent of your injuries.

    • 7
      careful-commuter740

      Solid advice. Getting it in writing is the part most people skip.

  • 9
    clever-swan-211

    Please don't let the legal stuff distract you from actually finishing your PT. Neck and shoulder injuries from rear-end collisions can feel manageable for months and then flare badly later — especially if you stop treatment early because you feel "good enough." Keep all your appointment records and don't skip sessions. That documentation matters medically AND for your case.

  • 12
    calm-seal-021

    One thing worth knowing: most states have what's called an "uninsured/underinsured motorist" provision on your own auto policy. Even if this driver's insurer ultimately pays, if there are gaps or they stonewall further, your own UM coverage can sometimes step in. Definitely worth a call to your own insurance to understand what you have — just don't record a formal statement with anyone until you know where you stand. Not legal advice, just process stuff.

  • 7
    hearty-kestrel-762

    Not legal advice, but the fact that the insurer is now calling you after service of process is a really common pattern. What matters now is that you don't negotiate directly with them without understanding the full value of your claim — lost wages, ongoing medical costs, pain and suffering. A lot of people settle too fast at this stage. At minimum, a free consult with a PI attorney before you talk numbers with them is worth your time.

    • 3
      patient-optimist258

      Appreciate the detailed write-up. Saving this for later.

  • 14
    quiet-vole-018

    You did the right thing. Some people only respond to consequences. Don't answer that insurance callback without a plan — decide in advance what your minimum acceptable outcome looks like, write it down, and don't let anyone pressure you on the phone into agreeing to anything on the spot.

    • 7
      hopeful-commuter143

      This is really helpful — thank you for posting it.

    • 3
      mellow-late-shift600

      Saving this whole thread. Really appreciate the honesty here.

  • 9
    bold-otter-339

    Honestly reading this stresses me out on your behalf. You did everything right and still got put through the wringer. I hope the lawsuit moves fast and you can just be done with all of it and focus on healing. Keep us posted please.