The Shoulder
The Shoulder
68
silent-swift-119

Arbitration ruled against me even with dashcam proof — what now?

I genuinely don't know where to go from here and I'm so frustrated I can't sleep.

A few months back I was backing out of my driveway onto a quiet side street. I checked both ways — nothing. I was already about halfway out when some guy came flying around the bend at the end of the block and clipped the rear quarter of my car. My vehicle actually has a collision-avoidance system that kicked in and brought me to a complete stop several seconds before impact. You can see it clear as day on my dashcam.

I also had a neighbor two houses down who had a security camera facing the street — so we're talking two separate video angles showing exactly what happened. The other driver had zero footage and no witnesses.

My insurance initially told me I looked good and not to stress. So I didn't. Then arbitration came back and basically said: you were the one exiting a driveway, so you had to yield, full stop. Deductible denied. Case closed.

Here's what kills me — I was stopped. My car stopped itself. I wasn't "backing into" anyone. He came around a corner fast enough that even my car's sensors freaked out. How is a driver supposed to yield to a vehicle that doesn't exist yet when you start pulling out?

My insurance is shrugging and saying arbitration decisions are final on their end. Is that actually true? Are my options completely gone here? Has anyone successfully pushed back after arbitration went the wrong way? I feel like the footage should have mattered way more than it apparently did.

12replies

Not sure what your claim is worth?

AskMatlock can connect you with an independent injury lawyer for a free case check — no pressure, no cost to start.

Check my case

0 / 4000 · posted under a randomly assigned handle

12 replies

  • 23
    daring-beaver-190

    Not legal advice, but worth knowing: arbitration outcomes in inter-company disputes (where your insurer and the other driver's insurer go head-to-head) are generally binding between the insurers, but that doesn't necessarily mean you have no options. Your right to pursue the other driver directly in civil court is a separate question from what your insurance company can or can't recover. Talking to a PI attorney about whether a direct claim against the other driver makes sense could be worthwhile — many do free consults. Again, not legal advice, just a direction worth exploring.

    • 4
      calm-passenger940

      Same boat here. Did anyone mention a deadline to watch out for?

  • 18
    tidy-bison-753

    A few things that might help you understand your position better:

    1. Ask your insurer for the full arbitration award document — you're entitled to know the reasoning. 2. Check whether your state has a process for appealing inter-company arbitration decisions (some do under specific circumstances). 3. Separately, your ability to file a claim or small claims action against the other driver personally may not have been affected by this arbitration at all — that's a different legal relationship.

    Definitely worth a free consult with a PI lawyer just to map out what doors are still open.

  • 18
    clear-owl-535

    Honestly? Stop expecting your insurance company to fight for you — they settled this in a way that was convenient for them, not necessarily fair to you. If the deductible amount is within small claims court limits in your state, look into filing against the other driver yourself. You have video from two angles. That's stronger evidence than most people walk into small claims with.

    • 0
      gentle-optimist493

      Solid advice. Getting it in writing is the part most people skip.

  • 17
    candid-mole-820

    Ugh, I feel this so much. I lost an arbitration decision a couple years ago even though I had a witness statement AND photos showing the other car crossed into my lane. The 'you had a duty to yield' logic gets applied super broadly and it's infuriating. I'm sorry you're going through this — it genuinely feels like the footage doesn't matter the way it should.

  • 17
    hearty-lynx-518

    This sounds absolutely exhausting. You did everything right — you had the footage, you had two angles, you were stopped — and it still went against you. I really hope you find a path forward. Please don't just let it go without at least talking to someone who can look at the full picture.

  • 17
    kind-seal-041

    Genuinely curious — did you have any legal representation during the arbitration process, or was it purely your insurance company handling it on your behalf? Because if it was just your insurer arguing the case, their interests and your interests aren't always perfectly aligned. That could matter a lot for figuring out what happened here.

    • 6
      mellow-co-pilot416

      Saving this whole thread. Really appreciate the honesty here.

  • 14
    spry-seal-551

    Insurance companies say 'nothing we can do' way too fast when it costs them less to just eat the loss and move on. I'd push back in writing and ask your insurer to explain specifically how the video evidence was weighed by the arbitrator. Get everything documented. They hate paper trails because it creates accountability.

    • 11
      swift-kestrel-436

      So the arbitration you're describing is almost certainly inter-company arbitration — it's basically your insurer vs. the other insurer arguing over who pays what. The arbitrator is often deciding on a very narrow legal standard, and 'exiting a driveway = duty to yield' is a shortcut a lot of arbitrators lean on hard regardless of the nuances. It's a crappy system. What I'd suggest: request a copy of the actual arbitration decision in writing. See what reasoning they used. That document can help an attorney figure out if there's any angle left.

    • 7
      swift-stoat-954

      Were you or anyone else injured in the crash? I ask because sometimes people get so focused on the property damage and deductible fight that they don't fully address physical stuff — even minor whiplash can show up weeks later. Just want to make sure you're taking care of yourself through all this stress, not just the car.